Tony Bennett’s Defeat’s Impact on the Common Core

Filed in Common Core State Standards by on November 15, 2012 3 Comments

Bennett1The education consulting group Whiteboard Advisors recently conducted surveys of 50-75 anonymous political and policy “insiders” before and after the election asking them to weigh in on a variety of issues.  One of the items that caught my eye they asked “How will Tony Bennett’s (the incumbent Indiana Superintendent of Public Instruction) defeat impact the Common Core?”  They asked the question of Indiana and then what national impact it might have.

Within Indiana:

  • “Common Core in Indiana is safe once Ritz realizes that NEA supports the standards and they gave
    her the money to be elected.”
  • “I think the Common Core will survive if teachers feel they are included in the implementation discussions.”
  • “I don’t know. Generally, the Common Core has a long way to go.”
  • “The Common Core has always been a Trojan horse to get out of accountability which they will do in other ways….”
  • “There will be a huge effort to get IN out of CC and PARCC.”
  • “Not sure if it will.”
  • “It’s apt to be a setback in IN and maybe set an ‘example’ for other states.”
  • “It’s not good news, but long‐term effect will depend on the State Board of Education.”
  • “I think there’s still a good chance that Common Core will survive.”
  • “Relatively little, will be hard for the state to pull out. National unions won’t be angling for it.  Bigger risk is to teacher evaluation law they passed.”
  • “Not clear. The problem for Common Core is that the funders and advocates are not effectively geared to the long and hard work of implementation. That’s CC’s greatest challenge.”
  • “Indiana will start to pull back, which will open the barn doors.”
  • “People in Indiana don’t see his defeat as having anything at all to do with Common Core.”

The last statement makes me shake my head.  Even Bennett pointed to his support of the Common Core as one of the reasons he lost.  Nationally about 30% didn’t think his defeat would make much of an impact.  Here are some of the “insider” comments.

  • “Nationally it is more complicated, the administration has put the standards in a
    tough spot by campaigning around them.”
  • “A few Republican legislatures and Governors will feel emboldened to make a run at Common Core, but the business community is organizing to defend the Common Core in states were they are threatened.”
  • “I think this in one of perhaps 6‐10 states that will start to slow walk the implementation of the Common Core.”
  • “The biggest loss will be felt on PARCC’s governing board.”
  • “It won’t defeat it nationally, but Common Core supporters must do a better job of explaining to policymakers what it is and why it matters.”
  • “Not much—the Common Core movement shouldn’t worry about one state as long as it still has a critical mass moving them forward.”
  • “Could have a chilling effect. Or, could wake the Common Core advocates up that they have a problem that is bigger than Jim Stergios and some bloggers.”
  • “The doomed enterprise heard the first tolling of the bells.”

Yes they do have a larger problem than some bloggers!  People read our blogs, they become informed and they act.  The last statement is my favoriate, “the doomed enterprise heard the first tolling of the bells.”  Yes!

Tags: , , ,

About the Author ()

Shane Vander Hart is the Editor-in-Chief of Caffeinated Thoughts, a popular Christian conservative blog in Iowa. He is also the President of 4:15 Communications, a social media & communications consulting/management firm, along with serving as the communications director for American Principles Project’s Preserve Innocence Initiative.  Prior to this Shane spent 20 years in youth ministry serving in church, parachurch, and school settings.  He has taught Jr. High History along with being the Dean of Students for Christian school in Indiana.  Shane and his wife home school their three teenage children and have done so since the beginning.   He has recently been recognized by Campaigns & Elections Magazine as one of the top political influencers in Iowa. Shane and his family reside near Des Moines, IA.  You can connect with Shane on Facebook, follow him on Twitter or connect with him on Google +.
  • tiredofgarbage

    My Mother lives in Southern Indiana-and though a school reform advocate/retired teacher and someone who is disgusted with the current public school education system and union control – said she and many voted against Bennett because they thought he was too showy, too into himself, and too self-promotional. She did not believe he really had the interests of either school reform or the children in mind, but his own benefit. Said he spent too much time hanging out with the money boys and was nothing but a Good ole Boy. So – though she voted Romney/Mourdock/Pence – and virtually NEVER votes for the Democrat, she didn’t vote “For” Bennett.

    • http://shanevanderhart.com/ Shane Vander Hart

      What did she think of Indiana’s involvement with the Common Core?

      • tiredofgarbage

        Doesn’t like it in any way, shape, or form. Sees the whole thing as a government control boondoggle of spending and foolishness. She retired about 5 years ago because she refused to deal with the administrative foolishness, and after a child hit her – but was never removed from her classroom.
        Now she tutors failing students. The local teachers send her everyone they can’t/won’t deal with. She charges a very good rate, and has them lined up at the door every day from 3:30 until 9:30p.m. – even Friday nights. And could all day on Saturday. And her students succeed. She focuses on Reading, Writing (including good cursive penmanship), and Math – drills, drills, and drills – as well as personal responsibility and self-control issues. Sit down, sit still, focus – and do your work. And if the child won’t get serious about their learning – or the parent doesn’t get them there – she kicks them out. And another one is waiting to take their place.
        Is a huge supporter of private schools/school choice. The money must follow the child.